Review by Nicholas Porteous for Mr. Will Wong
It’s 1986, and Irwin (Miles Teller), an engineer, lives happily with his wife Hester (Scarlett Johansson) and their two boys in a quiet New York neighborhood. One evening, his charming older brother Gary (Adam Driver), a retired cop and present-day entrepreneur, invites himself to dinner with an irresistible proposition: he wants to build a consulting business with Irwin–and he’s already got some clients with deep pockets. After Irwin signs up, the deal turns to quicksand, and the family struggles to escape from a terrifying world of crime and coercion. James Gray‘s Paper Tiger is a period drama about middle class people who are in way over their heads, but the tension ratchets so quickly and maintains such a tense hold on the audience, you wouldn’t be wrong to call it a Crime Thriller. The performances are so deeply felt and engrossing, it also plays like a character study.
Adam Driver is at the peak of his powers here, playing a slick, well-intentioned guy who seems to have all the answers. His charismatic disposition is a mask that almost never slips, but it’s clear there’s a vulnerable person hiding just beneath the surface, and the slow chipping away of that surface is absolutely riveting. Miles Teller beautifully threads the needle with what could have easily been a naive, woe-is-me character. Instead, it’s clear he’s a resourceful father doing his very best under impossible and horrifying circumstances. Meanwhile Scarlett Johnasson, while certainly a key player in the goings-on, essentially gets her own harrowing movie on the side. She’s just as brilliant and heartfelt as the rest of the phenomenal ensemble, playing in that same key–she’s a victim doing everything she can to manage her world as the walls inevitably close in.
Gray weaves these distinct threads into a rich fable about the strengths and limitations of family, the perils of ambition–even moderate ambition–and the small yet significant power we might preserve just as everything’s swirling down the drain. By the time the credits rolled on this relatively lean, 115-minute tale, I felt years had gone by. And I mean that in the best possible way. Don’t miss this gorgeously directed saga.
PAPER TIGER opens in Toronto theatres on November 20, 2026 and across Canada on November 27. 2026.
For advertising opportunites please contact mrwill@mrwillwong.com